This is supposed to be an article that focuses on healthy eating and bread spreads, but first a little perspective. Going back to my childhood, my family and I, but especially me, ate a lot of bread and any variety of it. We ate biscuits, rolls, bread pudding, sandwiches, and just bread by itself. I loved bread then and though I have personal restrictions in place, I love bread now. I get a warm feeling, probably originating from my stomach, just thinking about it and the many ways I consumed bread. If I was outside playing, it was easy to run into the house and grab a slice of bread and head back out. I would pack my jaw with the stuff (Wonder Bread was perfect for this) and like some sort of rodent nurse off of it until it was gone and then I would get another slice. Then there were the peanut butter and Alaga syrup sandwiches. Alaga is a cane sugar syrup, and it is darker and thicker than most syrups. I think it is a little sweeter too. It, the sandwich, tastes just like those “Maryjane” candies. Sticky and sweet…yum. Looking back, if there is one thing that put me on the track of being a diabetic, it was probably my love for bread and whatever I could put on it, which was almost always sweet and at portions that would probably kill me now.
Yes, I was a real bad bread lover. My brothers and I would have eating contests, like who could eat the most biscuits, rolls, pancakes (it’s not politically correct to say but we totally embraced the “Sambo” approach to eating pancakes) and syrup sandwiches or sopping syrup off of a plate that had margarine added to it. Boy if only I knew then what I know now.
So now I am a diabetic and my situation has made me more sensitive and smarter about what I consume and when I consume it. Now I only have 1 to 3 slices of bread a day and some days not even that. My choice of spread is still peanut butter but a small jar of preserves can last me two months easy. So what about the stuff we put on our bread, bagel or muffin? What’s good for you and what’s not so good? Thanks to the July/August of Diabetes Management magazine, I can tell you. Knowing more about the nutritional content of bread spreads and the right portion size may help you to prevent becoming a diabetic or help you in other ways, especially in losing weight. It is okay to use these products in small amounts, but let’s not do what I did as a child. Did it hurt, maybe not…but it certainly didn’t help either.
All of the bread spreads discussed here contribute calories in the form of fat, sugar, or both—but some are better choices than others. I hope that you can use this as a guide to help you to enjoy what you are eating while avoiding consuming too much saturated fat, trans fat, and sugar.
- Butter must be at least 80% milk fat by weight
- One tablespoon of butter contains 100 calories, 11 grams of fat (of which 7 grams are saturated fat and about ½ a gram is trans fat), and 30 milligrams (mg) of cholesterol.
- Whipped butter has fewer calories and less fat than regular butter. It has air whipped in during processing.
- One tablespoons of whipped butter contains about 70 calories, 8 grams of fat (5 of them saturated fat) and 20 mg of cholesterol.
- Light butter spread has even fewer calories and less fat than whipped butter. Some of the fat is replaced with water or gelatin.
- One tablespoon of light butter spread has about 60 calories, 7 grams of fat (2 of them saturated), and 7 mg of cholesterol.
American Diabetes Association Recommendation:
- Calories from fat should make up no more than 20% to 35% of the total calories you consume.
- In addition, 7% of your total calories come from saturated fat, and that you avoid trans fat whenever possible.
- A person that consumes 1,500 calories per day, this works out to about 33 to 58 total grams of fat, with no more than 12 grams of saturated fat.
- The ADA recommends a maximum daily cholesterol intake of 200 mg.
The reason behind these recommendations is that diets high in saturated fat and trans fat are believed to increase your risk of heart disease by raising blood levels of low-density lipoprotein (LDL, or “bad”) cholesterol, which promotes atherosclerosis (hardening and clogging of the arteries). A high intake of dietary cholesterol can also raise blood LDL cholesterol levels.
Consumers who want the taste of butter but less saturated fat may want to try products that blend butter with oil (usually canola, olive, soybean, and/or flaxseed oil). These products still have around 100 calories per tablespoon but only 4 grams of saturated fat per tablespoon. Oil-blended butters also come in light varieties, which decrease the calorie content to about 50 calories per tablespoon and the saturated fat to around 2 grams.
Brand Best Buy (serving 1 tbs.)
Challenge Spreadable Butter (Salted/Unsalted Whipped Butter): 70 calories; 7 grams of fat; 70 fat calories; 5 grams of saturated fat; 0 trans fat
Land O’Lakes Spreadable Butter (Salted Whipped Light Butter): 45 calories; 5 grams of fat; 45 fat calories; 3 grams of saturated fat; 0 trans fat
- Margarine is made from a single oil or a blend of oils and must contain at least 80% oil. (The other 20% is mostly water or nonfat milk).
- Margarine is most commonly made from soybean, corn, safflower, canola, cottonseed, and sunflower oils, and some products also contain olive or flaxseed oils.
- It is available solid, in sticks; soft, in tubs; even softer, in squeeze bottles; and liquid, in sprays.
- Regular margarine contains approximately 100 calories and 11 grams of fat, of which 2 grams are saturated, per tablespoon.
- Because margarine is made primarily from vegetable oil, it is cholesterol free. Cholesterol only occurs in foods of animal origin.
- Most of the fat in margarine is monounsaturated or polyunsaturated. These “fats” are known as “good” fats because they are good for your heart, your blood cholesterol levels and your overall health.
- One type of polyunsaturated, Omega-3 fatty acids, may be especially beneficial to your heart by protecting against irregular heartbeats and lowering the risk of heart attacks. Fish oil, which is high in omega-3 fatty acids, is added to some margarine products.
Does this mean I should switch back to margarine?
American Diabetes Association recommends…
That as a consumer you need to be careful and make sure you read the labeling of any margarine product. Some margarine products contain trans fat, which is created during food processing when liquid oils are solidified by adding hydrogen. (Trans fat also occurs naturally in small amounts in animal foods, which why butter contains some trans fat.) If the words “partially hydrogenated” appear in the ingredients list on a margarine package, the product contains trans fat. The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) allows food manufacturers to list 0 grams of trans fat in the Nutrition Facts panel if the food has less than half a gram per serving. If you eat more than one serving, though, it can add up.
- Margarine spreads are lower in fat than regular margarine because more water is added. Most spreads contain about 70 calories, 7 grams of fat, and 1-2 grams of saturated fat per tablespoon.
- Light margarine spreads are 50% lower in calories and fat than regular margarine.
All margarines (and most butter spreads) are supplemented with vitamin A, often in the form of beta-carotene. Some products are fortified with other vitamins and minerals. Margarines may also contain plant sterols, which lower LDL cholesterol without lowering HDL (high-density lipoprotein, or “good”) cholesterol.
Brand Best Buy (serving 1 tbs.)
Blue Bonnet (Soft Spread): 40 calories; 4 grams of fat; 40 fat calories; 1 gm. saturated fat; 0 trans fat
Country Crock Spreadable Margarine (Calcium Plus Vitamin D Fortified): 50 calories; 5 grams of fat; 50 fat calories; 1 gram of saturated fat; 0 trans fat
Fleischmann’s Original Spread (Olive Oil): 60 calories; 6 grams of fat; 60 fat calories; 1 gram of saturated fat; 0 trans fat
I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter (Calcium & Vitamin D or Light): 45 calories; 5 grams of fat; 45 fat calories; 1 gram of saturated fat; 0 trans fat
Parkay Spreadable Margarine (Light): 45 calories; 5 grams of fat; 45 fat calories; 1 gram of saturated fat; 0 trans fat
Smart Balance Spreadable Margarine (Light Omega-3 Buttery Spread): 50 calories; 5 grams of fat; 50 fat calories; 1 gram of saturated fat; 0 trans fat
- Cream cheese is an unaged cheese made from cow’s milk. Emulsifiers are used to make cream cheese firm. The USDA requires regular cream cheese to contain at least 33% fat and no more than 55% water.
- Cream cheese is high in calories, fat and saturated fat.
- Two tablespoons of regular cream cheese contain 90 calories, 9 grams of fat (of which 5 grams are saturated fat), 120 milligrams of cholesterol, and 2 grams of carbohydrate.
Spreadable cream cheese varieties include regular, whipped, light, one-third less fat, and fat free.
- Regular spreadable cream cheese contains 80 calories and 7 grams of fat (of which 4 ½ grams are saturated) per two-tablespoon serving.
- Whipped, light, and one-third less fat cream cheeses contain about 60-70 calories and 5-6 grams of fat (including 3 grams of saturated fat) per two-tablespoons.
- Fat-free cream cheese contains 30-40 calories per two-tablespoon serving.
- Fruit-flavored cream cheeses contain more carbohydrate (from added sugar) than the unflavored cream cheese: about 6 grams in two tablespoons.
- Flavored varieties, such as Kraft Philadelphia Snack Delights, which contain flavorings such as milk chocolate, dark chocolate, cinnamon, and caramel, can contain as much as 110 calories, 7 grams of fat (of which 4 grams are saturated), and 12 grams of carbohydrate in two tablespoons.
Brand Best Buy (serving 2 tbs.)
Philadelphia Fat Free: 30 calories
Philadelphia Fat Free (Strawberry): 40 calories
Philadelphia 1/3 Less Fat (Strawberry): 70 calories; 4 grams of fat; 40 fat calories; 2 trans fat
Jams, Jelly and Honey
Jam, jelly, fruit preserves, fruit butter, and honey are high in sugar and therefore high in calories and carbohydrates.
1st the Differences
- Jam is made from the pulp and juice of fruits and has a semi-gelled texture.
- Apricots, berries, plums and peaches are the most common fruits used to make jam.
- Jelly is made from just the juice and is clear and firm.
- Preserves are made from whole berries or uniform pieces of larger fruits, such as peaches and pears.
- Fruit butters are made from fruit that is cooked until softened, then processed into a smooth consistency. Peach, apple, pear, plum, and pumpkin are common fruit butter flavors, and spices such as cinnamon or cardamom are sometimes added.
Jams, jellies, preserves, and fruit butters taste sweet due to their fruit content, but many also contain added sweeteners. Always check for sources of added sugars on the ingredients list. Common nutritive (calorie-containing) sweeteners found in jam and jellies include corn syrup or high-fructose corn syrup (HFCS), which is a combination of fructose and dextrose.
Some products are sweetened with concentrated fruit syrup or fruit juice. However, those products, often labeled “100% fruit.” May be no lower in sugar and carbohydrate than products sweetened with sugar or corn syrup. Whatever the sweetener source, it’s important to check the Nutrition Facts panel on the label to know the carbohydrate content.
Honey is slightly higher in calories and carbohydrate than most jams and jellies. It contains 60 calories and 17 grams of carbohydrate per tablespoon.
Some food manufacturers make jams and jellies with a lower sugar and carbohydrate content. Being a diabetic means that this is what I spend my money on. Unfortunately most stores do not feature a wide variety of diabetic or sugar-free jams, jellies or preserves. Depending on their ingredients and calorie counts, these products may be labeled “low calorie,” “no sugar added,” “low sugar,” “light,” “sugar free,” or “reduced sugar.” In place of sugar or corn syrup, they may be sweetened with fructose, sugar alcohols, low calorie sweeteners such as aspartame or sucralose, or a combination of low-calorie sweeteners and sugar alcohols.
What do you know about sugar alcohols? I didn’t know much about them until after I became diabetic and I was encouraged to read the nutrition labels on what I was buying/eating. Sugar alcohols are a group of carbohydrates that have lower calorie counts than sugars and starches—about 2 calories per gram versus 4—because they are incompletely absorbed in the gut. Sugar alcohols you may see on ingredients lists include lactitol, mannitol, sorbitol, xylitol, isomalt, and hydrogenated starch hydrolysate.
Sugar alcohols are not considered sugars for labeling purposes but they are listed on the Nutrition Facts panel: Check for grams of sugar alcohols under total carbohydrate. Be aware that sugar alcohols have a laxative effect on some people—you may want to limit your intake.
Personally, I was told to avoid the “tol” group altogether. Sugar free does not mean carbohydrate free and I need to watch my consumption of carbs too.
Brand Best Buy (serving 1 tbs.)
Fifty50 Fruit Spread (Strawberry): 5 calories
Knott’s Berry Farm (Light Preserves, Strawberry): 20 calories
Smucker’s (Low Sugar, Strawberry): 25 calories
Smucker’s (Sugar Free, Concord Grape Jam w/Splenda): 10 calories
Smucker’s (Sugar Free, Strawberry Preserves w/Nutrasweet): 10 calories
Welch’s (Spread, Natural Strawberry): 30 calories
Welch’s (Reduced Sugar Spread, Strawberry Spread, Strawberry): 20 calories
Welch’s (Grape Jam or Jelly): 50 calories
Peanut Butter and Nut Spreads
PeaNUT…PEANUT BUTTER! Oh my god this is it…this is my favorite or should I say it’s my favorite right now. Before I was trying to mind my health, I was good for 3 or 4 peanut butter and strawberry/apricot/peach or cherry preserves sandwiches a day. My sandwiches were always thick with the preserves oozing out of the right places around the edge of the bread. The peanut butter was spread evenly across the bread (only white bread) and nowhere on the sandwich were the contents unevenly applied. My sandwiches where perfect! Thick! HEAVY!! A meal unto itself. Sadly, I can’t do that anymore L. My dietician says one slice of bread. It’s not a sandwich unless it has two. Who wins this debate? Most of the time I do (she’s not around to stop me), but I try to exercise a little harder and longer for my indulgence.
But, enough about me, lets talk about peanut butter and nut spreads. They are both made by grinding nuts into a paste. They can be “all natural,” meaning they are made just with nuts, or they can contain added oils, sweeteners, and other ingredients.
Peanut butter must contain a minimum of 90% peanuts with no artificial sweeteners or preservatives. Some brands add a stabilizer to keep the peanut butter fresh and the oil from separating; old-fashioned, or “natural,” peanut butter does not contain stabilizers, so the oil separates and must be stirred back in before using. Don’t pour off the separated oil, or the peanut butter will become too thick to spread.
· Peanut butter is a good source of protein, B vitamins, phosphorus, magnesium, and iron, but it also derives around 70% of its calories from fat.
· One serving of peanut butter is indicated on food labels as two tablespoons, and one serving contains 16-18 grams of fat, which includes 2-3 grams of saturated fat.
· Because partially hydrogenated oils are frequently added to achieve a creamy texture, peanut butter may contain added trans fat. Some, however, contain fully hydrogenated oils, which do not add trans fat.
· Peanut butter spreads were developed as reduced-fat alternatives to peanut butter. They contain 60% peanuts and provide 12 grams of fat and 2 grams of saturated fat per serving.
Please be aware that when fat is reduced, sugar is often added, which may increase the carbohydrate content. Since reduced-fat peanut butter is often not significantly lower in calories, and the carbohydrate content may double, there may not be significant health benefits to choosing it over regular peanut butter.
Another nut-based product that is growing in popularity is hazelnut spread. Hazelnut spread is a mixture of sugar, oil, hazelnuts, chocolate or cocoa, vanilla and milk.
- The best-known hazelnut spread, Nutella, contains 200 calories, 12 grams of fat (including 4 grams of saturated fat), and 21 grams of carbohydrate in two tablespoons.
- Nutella is higher in saturated fat than peanut butter because it contains palm oil, which is high in saturated fat, and its high amount of carbohydrate comes from added sugar.
- The protein content of Nutella is only 2 grams per serving, compared to 7 grams per serving in peanut butter.
- For a lower-sugar alternative try Justin’s Chocolate Hazelnut Butter, which contains 180 calories, 15 grams of fat (of which 3 grams are saturated), and 12 grams of carbohydrate per two-tablespoon serving.
Best Brand Buy (serving 2 tbs.)
Fifty50 (Creamy or Crunchy): 190 calories; 16 grams of fat; 140 fat calories; 2 grams of saturated fat
Jif (All varieties*): 190 calories; 15-16 grams of fat; 130-140 fat calories; 2-3 grams of saturated fat
*Jif Reduced Fat Creamy Peanut Butter Spread: 12 grams of fat; 100 fat calories; 2 grams of saturated fat
Laura Scudder’s All Natural Peanut Butter (Smooth Reduced Fat): 190 calories; 12 grams of fat; 110 fat calories; 2 grams of saturated fat
Peter Pan (Creamy Whipped): 150 calories; 12 grams of fat; 110 fat calories; 2 grams of saturated fat
Skippy (Natural Super Chunk, Reduced Fat Creamy/Super Chunk): 180 calories; 12 grams of fat (Natural Super Chunk 17); 110 fat calories (Natural Super Chunk 150); 2 grams of saturated fat (Natural Super Chunk 3)
Source: Diabetes Self-Management (July/August 2013) – “Bread Spreads” by Lea Ann Holzmeister, RD, CDE
- The Facts About Healthy and Unhealthy Dietary Fats (cholesterol.answers.com)
- Good vs. Bad Fats: What’s the Difference? (epicahealth.com)
- Butter vs. Margarine (familyfoodroots.wordpress.com)
- Good Fats and Bad Fats (2mailrishi.wordpress.com)
- Fatty Fat Fat (howardpower.wordpress.com)